Salient to Investors:
Hamilton “Tony” James of Blackstone Group said stocks were a fool’s game compared with alternative investments. and investing in alternatives makes sense even when they underperform. James said the return from these idiosyncratic investments are very uncorrelated to the broader markets, so portfolio volatility falls.
Hedge funds have been disappointing investors for years. Virtually every alternative investment category crashed in the financial meltdown of 2007 to 2009, none more severely than property, with housing and commercial real estate prices falling as much as 40 percent.
Bloomberg Markets says over the past three years to March 28, 2013:
- REITs gained more than any other alternative category: large-cap REITs returned 17.3 percent annualized versus private equity which returned 15.2 percent.
- The best-performing unconventional investments ranged from corn, 33.8 percent annualized, and silver futures, 20.5 percent annualized, to a Chateau Pavie Bordeaux and a 1957 Ferrari 250 Testarossa.
- Among the worst-performing alternatives were hedge funds, 3.3 percent, and funds of hedge funds, which lost money.
- The S&P 500 returned 12.7 percent annualized.
- For investors in real estate and REITs, valuations fell further and faster than other assets and have in the past three years jumped higher than the S&P 500.
- REITs that invest in shopping malls boasted the best performance with an annualized return of 25.3 percent. REITs that invest in self-storage units, industrial plants, health care, retail and Asian real estate produced 20 percent-plus gains.
- Hedge-funds invested in mortgage-backed securities gained more than 20 percent annualized
- Overall commodities returned 3.1 percent, but corn futures returned 33.8 percent.
- Classic cars and coins gained more than 15 percent annualized.
The poor performance of macro funds has been a reason for hedge funds’ overall mediocre 3.3 percent return.
Fund-of-funds have lost an annualized 3.8 percent over 3 years, while more than 600 funds of funds, or 25 percent of the total, have gone out of business since 2007.
Bob Rice at Tangent Capital Partners said things that are way down are going to come back, while central banks have given people a prevalence of cheap money to borrow and get back into alternatives such as real estate. Rice says you are starting to see more and more REITs that are borrowing to pay their dividends; a yellow flag to those chasing the asset class right now. Rice says private equity offerings to small investors is the next wave of alternative offerings.
REITs are a growing asset class in Europe and Asia.
Brian Hargrave at ZAIS Financial said the single biggest advantage of REITs is that they’re required to distribute at least 90 percent of their taxable earnings to shareholders as dividends.
The real estate moguls whose heavy borrowing helped fuel the 2008 financial crisis are back at it, taking advantage of Fed-driven low interest rates to amplify their returns through leverage.
David Fann at TorreyCove Capital Partners said real estate has been a huge beneficiary of QE so when central banks finally start raising interest rates, that could quickly end the new property boom and curtail the longer-term appeal of real estate investing. Fann said many of the large private equity deals that were undertaken during the boom period got salvaged because of quantitative easing.
Carl Friedrich at Piermont Wealth Mgmt said hedge funds in aggregate will more and more like the broader market as their asset base continues to grow.
Paul Ashworth at Capital Economics says corn and other agricultural commodities are a bubble which will burst in the next few years – low interest rates to buy farmland and higher yields for corn per acre.
Private equity, aka leveraged buyouts, has benefited greatly from the post-crisis low-interest-rate environment.
Preqin says global private-equity holdings surpassed $3 trillion of assets under management in 2011 for the first time and have continued to grow. KKR owns companies that employ 980,000 people. Blackstone’s more than 730,000, and Apollo’s 370,000.
David John at Brookings says if private equity offerings to small investors start to take hold, there needs to be either licensing, a seal of approval or some level of higher oversight so people don’t find that they are investing in unsuitable for their stage of life.
Read the full article at http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-07-10/property-crushes-hedge-funds-in-alternative-markets.html
Click here to receive free and immediate email alerts of the latest forecasts.